Watch
Canada–UK–EU Treaty
Eureka?Show notes
Andy Burnham heads to Brussels this week for a summit with the European Union, after telling the City of London that the hard Brexit Britain was given "is not good enough." Canada isn't waiting. Last month in Montréal, Mark Carney and the EU launched an Alliance for the Future, and Canada is on track to become the EU's first associate member.
Jeremy Purvis, Lord Purvis of Tweed, leads the Liberal Democrats in the House of Lords. He has a name for the next step: Eureka, a European, UK and Canada agreement. He and Andrew go back to the Brexit years, when they'd argue about Europe in meetings with visiting Canadian MPs and still enjoy each other's company afterwards. They still disagree, agreeably.
What we got into:
- What Eureka adds. When Graham Lanktree was on, he told us existing deals already cover 99 percent of Canada–UK trade. Jeremy's answer: a treaty gives the three a standing way to make decisions together and adapt over time, on defence procurement, intelligence sharing, police cooperation and climate rules. Tariffs aren't the big part. Regulation is.
- CANZUK or Brussels? Andrew points out that the right gets more excited about Canada, Australia, New Zealand and the UK than about Europe, and asks whether any of this needs Britain back in the EU. Jeremy wants Britain back as a full member one day, but sees Eureka as a stepping stone that works without it.
- Does a stronger European defence let America off the hook? Andrew's worry. Jeremy's answer: Sweden and Finland saw no contradiction between building Europe's own capacity and NATO.
- After the midterms. Is Europe relieved? Jeremy compares security guarantees to a £5 note: a promissory note, worth only as much as your trust in it. Andrew reads the results as MAGA voters staying home; Jeremy sees a bigger shift.
- What would Canadians actually gain? Joseph's dinner-table question. Jeremy: services, jobs, and recognition of professional qualifications, where Britain now needs 27 separate agreements ("bonkers"). Andrew adds shared procurement, the local-content rules that get in its way, and Canada's own barriers between provinces.
- What if the EU changes? Andrew raises Marine Le Pen and the AfD. Jeremy, a Scottish Liberal: "Once you've exhausted pessimism, there's only optimism left."
- Alberta. One in four Albertans voted to leave Canada last month. Jeremy's reflection from Scotland and Brexit: many who vote to shake things up because they feel they have nothing to lose stand to lose the most.
Also discussed: Liz Truss's Ten Years to Save the West, Andrew's application to become a Liberal Democrat peer (not accepted), and why BC is Scotland, only bigger.
Chapters
00:00 Welcome
01:04 Introducing Jeremy Purvis — Liberal Democrat leader in the House of Lords
01:24 The Brexit friendship — Agreeing to disagree across the Atlantic
04:16 What is EUR-UK-CA? — Formalizing Canada-UK-EU cooperation beyond trade
06:17 Canada's appetite for Europe — Associate membership and what it means
08:05 Defense procurement and SAFE — Where Canada is ahead of the UK
09:38 Does Eureka require EU membership? — Treaty arrangements without Brussels
13:07 The NATO question — Is Europe replacing America's security guarantee?
14:58 Trump's midterms and sovereign capability — Relief or false hope?
19:37 The promissory note problem — When security guarantees lose their value
25:30 What's in it for Canadians? — Services, qualifications, and employment opportunities
30:51 The populist problem on both sides — Reform UK meets the Greens
35:53 Lessons from Scottish independence — Alberta's referendum and the system not working
40:07 External interference and the sovereignty debate — Russia, tech giants, and disruption